Rimfire Central Firearm Forum banner
  • Whether you're a greenhorn or a seasoned veteran, your collection's next piece is at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.

    Advertisement

LGS FIND! -1953 Model 17, shamefully low price

9.8K views 43 replies 37 participants last post by  shovelhead96  
#1 · (Edited)
Sometimes ya just get hit in the face with the lucky stick! I had some time to kill this afternoon and stopped by my LGS to ask about ordering a Springfield Armory SA-35's (Hi Power clone), when something in the normally picked-over case caught my eye. It was a 1953 [Edit: 1952] S&W Model 17, S/N K 1647xx with pretty good bluing. Pinned barrel, recessed cylinder chambers etc. The real surprise. A yellow consignment ticket marked "$500" -- What!?? In today's nutty market that seemed like it was missing a "1" out in front of the "5" if you know what I mean. Didn't look like it had either been shot or carried a lot, although there was some faint wear at the muzzle from holster rub. I checked the trigger (S&W did/does such a nice job with them), looked at the rifling (present and correct), looked at the cylinder/forcing cone gap against the light, checked the lock up (tight), checked for wobble of the cylinder on the crane (none), checked the spring on the extractor/star (positive and snappy). Not a ton of wear on the checkering. It was the kind of experience where you turn your body a bit so other customers at the counter can't see what you are looking at. At that price, it only took about five minutes to decide. Despite a recent and ill-conceived "no-buy" pledge, out came the plastic and I walked out the door for $500 plus tax. Oh, the salesman at the counter said "wait a minute" and disappeared into the back. I thought he was going to re-price the thing after the sale. Nope. The consignment customer also dropped off an embossed cowboy style leather belt and holster with loops for ammo in the back. "You want this?" asked the salesman. "It came in with the pistol." Gak! Turns out the revolver was dropped off that morning on consignment and it had only been in the case a couple of hours.

The revolver looks like this:

Image


Image


Now where'd I put that Lottery ticket? . . .
Hope you all are having as good a day. They don't come along all that often.

Edit: [Oooops. Supica & Nahas say the s/n dates from 1952, not 1953 as I said in the thread title. No matter -- I think of those years as the Golden Age of American firearms manufacturing for revolvers like these. ]
 
#4 ·
Mistakes happen and you were the lucky recipient this time around. I am sure somebody at that store dropped the ball so to speak.The LGS lost a lot of money and the previous owner lost out as well. Probably a widow wanted it out of the house and knows nothing about guns.Anyway a very nice K22 . They do not make them like that anymore. I have a K22 that I bought 20 years ago and I thought I was getting a deal at 500 dollars.
 
#10 ·
I'm a 1952 model. I should have that rig!

Many years ago, I lucked into a perfect Model 17-4. A new arrival, priced by a young clerk.
"Just a .22", was his thinking. He was all about guns being tactical. The gun was easily worth twice the price.
Thing was, they also had a K22 in the case, not so pristine, that was priced where such a gun should have been. I guess the owner didn't notice the discrepancy.
 
#17 ·
Finding an old , clean 17 is a rare find in itself. Too find one at that price is amazing. Hope you stopped at church on the way home to do some penance :)

Seriously, finds like that are what keeps me haunting mom and pop gun shops on a regular basis. Nothing feeds the addiction like when you hit a deal on something you love. It makes it all worthwhile!
 
#36 ·
Finding an old , clean 17 is a rare find in itself. Too find one at that price is amazing. Hope you stopped at church on the way home to do some penance :)

Seriously, finds like that are what keeps me haunting mom and pop gun shops on a regular basis. Nothing feeds the addiction like when you hit a deal on something you love. It makes it all worthwhile!
Ma and pop gun stores are becoming rare, we must support them. Stay away from the big box stores that are out of state, they won't help your local community. Here in rural New Hampshire we've lost two good stores around me, one sold real black powder, that was a real loss.
 
#21 ·
I got a few K22s myself. I just had out my 1958 Stoger Shooters Bible to look up Llama 22 pistols. In 1958 a K22 was $81 large, the 41 was a cool $100. Both a tidy sum back then. You have to adjust for the dollar. You are talking over a weeks pay for some in early 50s. You didn’t see a lot of them. Was hard to justify that kind of money for a 22 pistol. I got my first one new in 1964? I was a thing of awe compared to what we were use to.
I just traded a Hi-Std HD Military for a very nice 1950 K22. They are going for decent money. $750-$1K. I would jump on any for $500, in reasonable shape. They were dragging behind in S&W line up. 3 yrs ago K22, K38, m19 and m28s were fairly reasonable. The top has been found in the popular models and now the others are coming up to meet them.
There is no more of these revolvers being made. The present production may be same model but they don’t hold a candle to the older guns. Just about any S&W with adjustable sights in this time period is going to be close to $1K.
 
#22 ·
I got a few K22s myself. I just had out my 1958 Stoger Shooters Bible to look up Llama 22 pistols. In 1958 a K22 was $81 large, the 41 was a cool $100. Both a tidy sum back then. You have to adjust for the dollar. You are talking over a weeks pay for some in early 50s. You didn't see a lot of them. Was hard to justify that kind of money for a 22 pistol. I got my first one new in 1964? I was a thing of awe compared to what we were use to.
I just traded a Hi-Std HD Military for a very nice 1950 K22. They are going for decent money. $750-$1K. I would jump on any for $500, in reasonable shape. They were dragging behind in S&W line up. 3 yrs ago K22, K38, m19 and m28s were fairly reasonable. The top has been found in the popular models and now the others are coming up to meet them.
There is no more of these revolvers being made. The present production may be same model but they don't hold a candle to the older guns. Just about any S&W with adjustable sights in this time period is going to be close to $1K.
Was just watching a auction on sunday I think every smith and wesson revolver that was clean and nice brought at least 1100 dollars without the 15% buyer premium and fees. Both the model 41 s that were collector status were 1350 and 1400 dollars plus the fees and buyers premium.If you have nice stuff to sell it is definitely a sellers market.
 
#25 ·
Great deal on a great revolver! Cool story, too.
I happened upon a minty 1954 Masterpiece K-22 about a year ago. I got an even more incredible deal....free.

Yes, free. My father-in-law gave me several firearms. In addition to the K-22 was a 1939 Winchester 94 and an old 1920's Iver Johnson in 38 S&W. The only condition is that I give them to my grandsons (his great grandsons) when they are old enough. No problem with that deal. :)
 
#29 ·
I know this is an older post but this is the 17-2 that showed itself in the local "Tactical" GS glass case. When I saw it had a set of N frame presentation grips and a target hammer and trigger I was guessing someone had used it for paper match work. Then I tried the single action and knew that its previous owner had made some magic happen. It has a fair share of honest holster wear and a few deeper finish marks from lack of an oil wipe down before long storage. But the barrel is immaculate on the inside and it shoots to the sights better than any other K frame I own. Came across the set of dark inner metal disc Magna's at a local swap meet for very cheep. Still looking for a crisper set that are not $$$$. Feel lucky to have found this and like the OP couldn't get the cash out fast enough when I saw the asking price. Better yet it came with the nice Basket Weave holster. Perfect for the trap line or the farm.
Its my favorite 22 to knock about with.

Image