Rimfire Central Firearm Forum banner
  • Whether you're a greenhorn or a seasoned veteran, your collection's next piece is at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.

    Advertisement

CMP Winchester 52D Value?

2.6K views 15 replies 8 participants last post by  Pastprime  
#1 ·
Guys, I need some help here regarding valuation of a 52D that I obtained many years ago from the CMP. I have the CMP provenance as well if that makes any difference regarding current value (I doubt it). To be clear, I'm NOT offering the rifle for sale here. My situation is that a friend of mine would like to buy the rifle, and while I want to treat him as such (as a friend, that is), I don't want to shortchange myself too badly regarding price. No doubt I'll be replacing the 52 with something else down the road. So "friend(ly)" discount applies. I don't REALLY want to sell it, but my friend has been bugging me about it, and I've another, similar condition 52D in my stable to shoot so no worries there... OK--So the rifle itself is a run-of-the mill CMP 52D, I would say in about average condition. That is, it has the usual, but minor, CMP handling marks/scratches on the Marksman stock and also on the barreled action. Anyone that has purchased from the CMP (this one was NOT handpicked by me, but shipped to my door) will know what I'm talking about. Bluing is surprisingly good though. I've not done a thing to the rifle. It shoots like one would expect a 52D to shoot, that is, pretty darn good. I actually won a few local matches with it. If a few of the brethren would see fit to respond here and give me a price range to consider, I would very much appreciate it.
 
#7 ·
I can't add anything to suggested value as I'm out of touch on 52Ds. I sold an average CMP model for about $1000 several years ago.

I have found that commercial models of military trainers generally are more rare, have less use, are in better shape and therefore bring more than CMP models. I don't believe that the CMP provenance adds anything unless a buyer wants an ex-military rifle for personal reasons. In short, as Shorty said (excuse the pun) condition and original "extras" affect the value.

I say this because even the more rare CMP military versions I have owned, (52C AFPG Air Force Premium Grade and 40X USMC) brought no more than a commercial model and I really pushed the provenance in the ads. Even the story about Curtis Lemay's involvement with the AFPG. I remember one fellow commented "nice story, good luck." I don't think General LeMay had any effect on the price realized.

I recently sold a very nice commercial 40XB for more than I have seen any CMP 22 rifle go for, in part because it came with the Remington paperwork, sights and handstop which generally won't be had with CMP rifles. And it was likely under-priced because it went immediately without a counter-offer. The point is I believe something like the original instructions, sights, or even the handstop are generally worth a lot more than the CMP certificate...Tom


Image


Image
 

Attachments

#8 ·
Tom, nice pic of the instruction sheets and accys for the 40X. That stuff certainly adds value to any sale. I have a CMP 40XB "heavy" also, and that one is my favorite benchrest rifle and I use it a lot in local ARA-style (the 25 bull ARA unlimited target is used for these) matches. But getting back to the 52D---Thanks to all that responded so far. Shorty indicated a current starting price of around $1200, and perhaps apply the "friendly" discount to that? Others please feel free to opine as well. My friend is more of a collector than a shooter, but having said that, I'm pretty sure he will be shooting the 52 just a bit. I don't think he will be able to stop himself:). IF I can bring myself to turn loose of that rifle:unsure:, I'll need to be sure I can find the aforementioned CMP paperwork and that handstop. It IS around here somewhere....
 
#11 ·
Dang, I guess I missed that one.... And I do usually look at the classifieds quite often. So $1250 for that one... Hmmnn.... The stock is definitely nicer than mine (less handling marks, etc), but then again it's missing that sling mount (important to a collector, I imagine, but a shooter could care less) and it has an "E" loading tray, and no original handstop (same applies I would think). So it looks like maybe around $1000, give or take a few bucks, to my friend:unsure:? Anyone think that is NOT fair deal for a "friendly" sale? Just looking for affirmation is all, and I don't want to be a horse's arse in this case. While this is NOT a super close friend, but still a friend nonetheless. And we all need our friends, and hope they would reciprocate if the roles were reversed, right?:).