Rimfire Central Firearm Forum banner
  • Whether you're a greenhorn or a seasoned veteran, your collection's next piece is at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.

    Advertisement

Charcoal Lighter and Lighter Fluid

2.3K views 18 replies 14 participants last post by  jcwit  
#1 ·
Is charcoal lighter the same as lighter fluid? I use lighter fluid to clean triggers but ran out yesterday. I've got a couple of big cans of charcoal lighter, but can't tell from the labels if it is the same chemically as lighter fluid. Thanks.
 
#14 ·
Pardon the rant, but I am a nurse in a burn icu.
For God's sake, use gun cleaner for your guns, didn't someone just mention Breakfree--good enough for the US Army good enough for me. Lighter fluid is FOR LIGHTERS. Charcoal fluid is for BBQ's (if you don't mind your food tasting like petrol).
I can't count the number of tragedies I've seen that start with, "Well, I was cleaning my widget with gas (lighter fluid, nitro methane, ether....) and next thing I knew it's two months later and I'm waking up in your ICU."
 
#17 ·
Everything else that's accessible gets cleaned with WD-40. Inexpensive and very effective.
I had a bad experience with WD-40 taking the bluing off a revolver. Did anyone else have this problem? I once purchased an old rusted-closed Mauser action of some sort, comolined, but the bolt was rusted in place. I soaked it in a barrel of delicious Diesel at a friends shop and it freed it up.
 
#19 ·
Regarding the orginal question, no they are not the same. Liter fluid is nothing more than NAPTHA, AKA as white gas, or Coleman fuel for the lantern or stove.
Yes you can use Coleman fuel for your Zippo liter even tho "its not made specifically for use in a liter. Will also work great as a cleaner on triggers or other small gun parts as it is nothing more than a petro solvent. Matter of fact it will clean most any parts that does not have burned on/in carbon.
Charcoal Liter is somewhat the same as a higher refined Kerosene or paint thinner AKA mineral spirits. Not as good as a cleaner and a little more oiler, but it also can be used for other purposes other than what it was packaged for. It will not everapate as quick and will leave a residue.

Never heard of WD-40 removing bluing in my 50+ years of cleaning firearms. Sounds like there was some water present.