I was originally drawn to Appleseed because of the military type influence on the COF. I like the COF as is, it's great for training novices as well as those who think their "proficient" already.
I also like that we are allowing .22 rimfires on the line for just the sheer economy of it. This has really opened up things for a lot of people. Rifles in mind, semi-automatics with box magazines and bolt actions with box magazines.
Things I personally do not like are tube fed rifles of any kind, lever actions and single shots on the line. I believe these rifles, because of their very nature of mechanics takes away from the COF and the experience and ability for the student to soak up the training. These types of rifles are an unnecessary obstacle for training for the AQT.
.22 rimfires were encouraged to be used because of the economy of ammunition used, everyone could not afford the centerfire rifles and ammunition commonly used before. I believe if you are going to use a rimfire, why not one with sights similar to a Main Battle Rifle and with a box magazine for rapid magazine changes? After all, the AQT was designed with Main Battle Rifles in mind, so if you are going to use a .22 training rifle it should mimic an MBR as closely as possible.
I know that what I have said here will not be popular with some, but all of this business with accomodating those with tube fed rifles just takes away good instructional time from other students. Especially when you have to accomodate those who are unfamiliar with their own equipment! And using this type of rifle just for the challenge? I don't really understand the reason for this, but by all means if you are already a proficient Rifleman, go for it!
Another thing, if you don't like the Appleseed program, go start your own program!
You naysayers belong somewhere else!
I'm an ol' U.S. Army Infantry Veteran, I have been around firearms all of my life, even before Appleseed, I was once a Rifle Instructor stationed at Fort Leonardwood, Missour teaching young Basic Trainees....I know for a fact, the Appleseed course of instruction is superior to the COF provided to US Army Istructors by the Training and Doctrine Command(TRADOC). The Army doesn't teach shooting with a sling anymore and hasn't in decades, does not teach acquiring NPOA, and other things I do not have time to list.
I for one, am one who would like to adhere to the roots of Appleseed as much as possible, I remember reading Fred's articles in ShotgunNews, very interesting reading! Fred has taken a softer approach to his writings and ideas in the last few years, but I'm sticking to Appleseed, it's the best we have!