Here is a good article by the NRA on the above topic
The 22 LR for self defense
The 22 LR for self defense
Whether you're a greenhorn or a seasoned veteran, your collection's next piece is at Bass Pro Shops. Shop Now.
A locked breech gun in 380 has far less "recoil" than a 32 using straight blowback . Witness the Spanish Llama , or the CZ27 and CZ24 . Compare a Remington 51 with a Browning 1910/1955 .Okay, who's bringing the popcorn on this one?
Big drawback on .22 for SD is the fact that rimfire ignition is not as dependable as centerfire. .25 has about the same ballistics as .22 LR, so I did move up another notch and carry .32 ACP.
I get flamed a lot for that, but I don't care. Most people consider .380 as the rock bottom choice, but .380 gives only a slight improvement in ballistics, at a cost of nearly double the recoil of .32.
This is a great answer as to when is the .22 suitable for self defense. It's suitable when you don't have anything else. For me a 9mm is about the smallest caliber I feel comfortable with for self defense. Anyone who can't handle the recoil of a 9mm hasn't shot enough to be safely carrying any firearm.When it was the only pistol I had I kept my 22/45 target (with red dot) on the nightstand.
In a perfect world you may be able to predict what the situation will be if you ever come under threat (actually in a perfect world it would never happen). The problem is most people never expect to have to use a firearm in self defense, never mind know what the situation will be. And most of the time the sight or sound of a firearm probably is enough to send a bad guy running. But how do you predict a situation where someone is hell bent on taking lives? What if your sitting in your favorite restaurant and some maniac comes in and starts executing people? I realize that this is an extreme case but it's also one that can and has happened in the past. Or your walking down a city Street and some junky that's high on pcp decides he wants to rob you or worse. Unfortunately things like this happen all the time. I do my best to try to keep myself out of any situation where I think a problem could arise, but unfortunately I'm no psychic.First, my goal is to escape any situation with my wife and me in good condition, not to have a shootout with the threat. Where do we go where we might come under assault? Well, Walmart, gas station, stop light, and maybe some of the restaurants we prefer. who do I expect the bad guy to be? I don't expect some hardened criminal out to make sure I am going to die. I expect any situation I might find myself in would involved would be with someone taking advantage of an old couple by snatching a purse, car jacking, or petty theft. With this in mind, I believe the bang and the flash play a significant part in the equation. (and yes I've be ridiculed for years for this belief)
A handgun in .22 or .25 is sufficient in the situation described to make sure we can escape danger. Again, my goal isn't to kill the bad guy or stand and fight, but to escape.
I agree completely and as I said earlier I always carry unless I'm on the way to the local Air Force Base where it is against the law.I also believe that a firearm with no round in the chamber is a very poor rock.
VHman:
Not this "they".....its so I can fight my way to my next pistol.And like they say a pistol is only so you can fight your way to your rifle. :bthumb: