Using a brush for the acid will not be enough. Tell him to plug the bore, fill it with acid, and let it sit overnight.
Muriatic acid is another name for HCl (hydrochloride acid), which is great at eating clothing, and very dangerous to eyes, skin and lungs. Vinegar, various types, is 5% acetic acid—-ever so much safer. HCl gas is a respiratory danger. HCl left in contact with ferrous metals will produce ferrous chloride and hydrogen gas. HCl and copper will also release hydrogen gas.I used to use Muriatic acid to clean rust off of steel that I needed to weld on. It is nasty stuff, I hope he knows how to handle it safely!
I can't imagine that it will hurt the bore, but it probably won't do any of the finishes any good. Unless he plans to leave in the bore for weeks or longer. Then it will likely damage the bore. Neutralizing it will be nearly or more damaging than the acid itself. It will remove every trace of oil in the steel and that steel will flash rust unless oiled immediately. As in don't dry the bore from the neutralizing water flush, use an oiled patch to remove the water from the bore.
If he still feel the need to use an acid on the bore suggest that he use white vinegar instead. It is a fairly strong Citric Acid and is what I now use to clean the rust off of steel that I need to weld on. Nearly as effective and a whole lot safer to handle.
Vinegar & hydrogen peroxide is a better idea to remove leading.so i think this is a bad idea & i'm looking for reinforcement. a friend found an abused 39A for cheap. he's in the process of cleaning it up & thinks that running a cleaning brush dipped in muriatic acid several times thru the barrel will clean the bore. i told him that it will likely do some serious damage. what do y'all think? i did see on one of those true crime shows i saw where a guy did this trying to change the rifling so the gun couldn't be matched in a criminal ballistics tests but that's not the goal here.
So you want to use hydrogen peroxide. Here's the opinions concerning concentrations and use, from chemists.Vinegar & hydrogen peroxide is a better idea to remove leading.
Interesting for sure, all I can say is an 1873 44-40 with no visible rifling had a 24 hr soak with black foamy gunk pouring out. Rifling was showing but as it was found in a barn & had been there for yrs, bore was about same condition as exterior. My opinion before starting was: it was not a Turnbull candidate and a half box of ammo later it was a shotgun. So a $3k gun with $4.5k of resto was still going to be a $3k wall hanger. Nothing ventured and no high pressure later from fouled bore I think I was close.So you want to use hydrogen peroxide. Here's the opinions concerning concentrations and use, from chemists.
![]()
Chemical Forums: Reaction between Hydrogen Peroxide and Lead
Reaction between Hydrogen Peroxide and Leadwww.chemicalforums.com
**
At least one of the Notable F-Class shooters likes CLR. I use it to clean fired brass. It really goes after carbon and rust. I doubt it does much for lead fouling. Chemistry is wrong.Starting with clr instead would be way less awful
The chemistry is right for using CLR to attack barnacles and such. It will decimate the calcium long before it will damage brass. But, it will etch brass if you leave it too long. Muriatic (Hydochloric) acid is commonly used to clean calcium from hard water off of porcelain (toilets).Way back when we use to use MA to clean boat propellers. It worked great. You just can't leave it on there to long. You have to have something to neutralize it. With a prop it was fresh water....with a gun???
there is some good popcorn on post 40.Popcorn? I like popcorn!! Lmao
Tell your friend to put that Muriatic acid on his hands...... that will give him his answere to his really stupid query. Consider your true crime show example. The criminal was using acid toso i think this is a bad idea & i'm looking for reinforcement. a friend found an abused 39A for cheap. he's in the process of cleaning it up & thinks that running a cleaning brush dipped in muriatic acid several times thru the barrel will clean the bore. i told him that it will likely do some serious damage. what do y'all think? i did see on one of those true crime shows i saw where a guy did this trying to change the rifling so the gun couldn't be matched in a criminal ballistics tests but that's not the goal here.